Decades of knowledge, always close to home.
NANCY
SCHAEFER
Book an appointment.
With more than 30 years of experience in both residential and commercial real estate, Nancy has worked across the South Shore from Moriches to Oakdale. She has lived in Brookhaven Hamlet and now calls East Patchogue home, always choosing to live close to the water and beaches that define this area.
Nancy brings decades of market knowledge and a deep appreciation for the coastal lifestyle to every client relationship. Her long-standing connection to the South Shore allows her to offer thoughtful guidance and steady insight to those buying, selling, or navigating their next chapter.
Call / Text / 516-238-0518
Email / NancyJ1@optonline.net
Book a Consultation
If you’re exploring your options, we’ll show you around — the area, the process, or the market. Share what you’re thinking about, and we’ll guide you through what matters most.
Your Next Chapter Starts Here
-
![A large gray house with a gabled roof and multiple windows, surrounded by lush green trees. In front of the house, there is a rectangular swimming pool with a paved patio area. Potted plants and blooming flowers are around the pool, and the scene appears to be on a bright, sunny day in a well-maintained yard.]()
Water Views, Village Living
13 Peathole Lane | Under Contract
Bellport Village South
5 Bedrooms | 4.5 Baths | Gourmet Kitchen with Sub-Zero & Wolf Appliances and Two Oversized Islands | Radiant Heat | 5-Zone Central Air | 50-Foot Gas-Heated Pool | Expansive Patios | 2-Car Garage | 1.26 Acres
Annie Rohrmeier
-
![White multi-story house with green front door, brick pathway, well-manicured yard, and large trees.]()
1836 Colonial in the Historic District
46 Bellport Lane | Under Contract
Bellport Village South
6 Bedrooms | 3.5 Baths | 1 Fireplace | Heated Pool w/ Jacuzzi | Eat-in Kitchen | Central Air | Lush Landscaping | Huge Entertaining Screened Porch | 66 Acres
Annie Rohrmeier
-
![A two-story house with shingle siding, black front door, and white trim, surrounded by green trees and a well-maintained lawn.]()
Private Retreat with Freshwater Pond
6 Prairie Lane | $1,750,000
Brookhaven Hamlet
4 Bedrooms | 2.5 Baths | Eat-in Kitchen | 2 Car Attached Garage | Freshwater Pond | Large Entertaining Deck | Detached Studio | 1.03 Acres
Monica Schleede
-
![A white house with large front windows and a small front porch, surrounded by green trees and a well-maintained lawn, under a clear blue sky.]()
Charming Abode with Heated Pool
45 New Jersey Avenue | Under Contract
Bellport Village
3 Bedrooms | 1.5 Baths | 1 Fireplace | Heated Salt Water In-Ground Pool | Outdoor Shower | Outdoor Deck | Central Air
Christine Schaeffer
-
![146 Old Stump Rd.]()
Backyard Oasis with Stunning Gardens
146 Old Stump Rd. | Under Contract
Brookhaven Hamlet
2 Bedrooms | 2.5 Baths | 1 Fireplace | Central Air | In-Ground Pool with Cabana and Outdoor Shower | 4+ Car Parking | .92 Acres
Ed Palace
-
![A house with a brown roof, green exterior, and white window frames with navy shutters, surrounded by well-manicured lawn and bushes, with a small shed nearby, under a blue sky with some clouds.]()
Classic Village Living, Timeless Charm
5 Bayview St. | $850,000
Bellport Village
2 Bedrooms | 1 Baths | Nice Sized Kitchen | Hardwood Floors | Room for pool with variance | 1 Car Detached Garage | 0.24 Acres
Nancy J.Schaefer
-
![A house with white siding and a gray roof surrounded by green grass and trees, including one with white blossoms, under a clear blue sky.]()
Meticulous Ranch, Beautiful Landscaping
5 Stillwood Rd. | Under Contract
Brookhaven Hamlet
3 Bedrooms | 2.5 Baths | Remodelled Kitchen | Hardwood Floors | 1.5 Car Detached Garage | 1.01 Acre | Large Entertaining Patio | Stunning Gardens
Christine Schaeffer
-
![A white house with blue trim and a small front porch, surrounded by a garden with pink and purple flowers, a white picket fence, a green lawn, and a blue SUV parked on the driveway under a clear blue sky.]()
Charming Cottage, Vintage Beachy Vibe
68 George St. | Under Contract
East Patchogue
2 Bedrooms | 1 Bath | White Galley Kitchen | 2+ Car Parking | Hardwood Floors | Entertaining Patio | Stunning Backyard | .25 Acres
Monica Schleede
-
![A two-story house with white siding, blue trim, and a small front porch with steps, surrounded by a well-maintained garden with bushes, flowering plants, and grass, under a clear blue sky.]()
Circa-1919 Charm, Garden Privacy
65 Hedges Rd. | Under Contract
East Patchogue
4 Bedrooms | 4 Baths | Updated Kitchen | Hardwood Floors | Central Air | 2 Driveways | 0.80 Acre | Entertaining Patio | Room for Pool
Leslie Healy
-
![An aerial view of a suburban neighborhood with houses, trees, a pond, and a golf course in the background.]()
Modern farmhouse in the heart of the Village
36 South Howells Point Rd. | Just Sold!
Bellport Village South
4 Bedrooms | 3.5 Baths | Large Open Kitchen with 6 Burner Stove, Island, & Skylights | Central Air | Gunite Salt Water Pool | Large Entertaining Patio | 2 Car Parking | 0.60 Acres
Annie Rohrmeier
-
![Aerial view of a white house with a gray roof, surrounded by trees and green lawn, overlooking a large body of water in the background.]()
Great South Bay Views, Golf Course Living
281 Woodacres Rd. | Just Sold!
East Patchogue
2 Bedrooms | 1.5 Baths | Large Updated Kitchen | Entertaining patio | Large Shed | Views of Bellport Golf Course | .1.25 Acres
Christine Schaeffer
-
![A white two-story house with a black roof and red brick chimney, surrounded by a well-maintained green lawn and bushes, on a clear day with blue sky.]()
1929 Dutch Colonial-Style Home
11 Hulse St. | Temporarily off the market
Bellport Village South
3 Bedrooms | 1.5 Baths | 1 Fireplace | Detached 1 Car Garage | Private Driveway | .27 Acres | Close to Country Club and Waterfront
Annie Rohrmeier
-
![A two-story house with a brown shingled roof, surrounded by a landscaped yard with bushes and trees. There is a driveway with a circular design and a garage. The backyard has a pool, a covered patio, a small shed, and a grassy area with trees.]()
Stately Colonial, Big-Family Haven
15 Stillwood Rd. | Just Sold!
Brookhaven Hamlet
4 Bedrooms | 3.5 Baths | 1 Fireplace | Central Air | Pool with Pool House | Large Entertaining Patio | 2 Car Attached Garage & 3 Car Detached Garage | 1.81 Acres
Christine Schaeffer
-
![Large modern house with a distinctive roof design, surrounded by green trees and a well-maintained lawn, with a white golf cart parked in the driveway.]()
Elevated Living on the South Shore
293 Beaver Dam Rd | Just Sold!
Brookhaven Hamlet
4 Bedrooms | 3.5 Baths | Eat-in Kitchen with Stainless Appliances | Gunite Pool with Jacuzzi | Solar Heat | Central Air | Surround Sound | 1.78 Acres
Monica Schleede
-
![A single-story house with a brown roof, white exterior, and large front windows, surrounded by bushes and trees, with a front yard that has patches of snow and dry grass.]()
Garden Sanctuary, Village Charm
41 Country Club Rd | Just Sold!
Bellport Village
3 Bedrooms | 2 Baths | Entertaining Deck and Patio | Stunning Landscape | Potting Shed | 2 Car Attached Garage | .33 Acres
Christine Schaeffer
-
![A suburban house with brown shingle siding, surrounded by leafless trees and a well-maintained lawn, under a clear blue sky.]()
Village Living with Bay Views
149 Munsell Rd. | Just Sold!
East Patchogue
3 Bedrooms | 2.5 Baths | Eat-In Kitchen | Living Room with Wood Burning Fireplace | In-Ground Pool | .60 Acres
Christine Schaeffer
